Lead Holder Vs. Mechanical Pencil – Know The Differences

No matter what we say, pen or pencil, these are some of the most used tools in almost every function of our daily lives.

Are there fewer pencil options in the market? Of course not; anyone looking at the variations of the pens is likely to get dizzy. But, if you want to know which pen is best for you, we have not chosen two different pencils like lead holder vs. mechanical pencil is enough to give any user a fine idea.

lead holder vs mechanical pencil

Consequently, the reason for choosing these two pencils is that although sketching is excellent for drawing or writing, there are advantages as well as disadvantages.

Generally, it is regarded as a less appreciated and neglected class of stationery, while mechanical pencils have been placed in the sophisticated twilight zone. Have you ever wondered how these two ends would be tied together? No worries, we are going to discuss that topic in this article.

The Preliminary Comparison Between The Lead Holder And Mechanical Pencil

If you can’t enjoy the job using a simple wooden pencil, you should consider a lead holder or a mechanical pencil. But on the condition that you have to choose one, it’s imperative to have a basic idea about the first two pencils.

Yes, it is acknowledged that both mechanical pencils and lead holders are pretty good in their own right, but their manufactured material, type, and structure are entirely different.

Consequently, anyone wants to know the answer to all these questions; you have to look into the definition of the lead holder and mechanical pencil.

What Is Lead Holder?

what is lead holder

A lead holder is a thicker piece of graphite than a regular pencil that can hold the lead, such as 2 millimeters or above. Lead holders are essentially the same lead type for different types and sizes of lead thickness whose refill leads are sold separately in the market, and the container lasts longer.

In particular, the lead holder pencils use a clutch mechanism to hold the lead, which simply means that the knock is applied to the knob as the lead is pushed out by gravity. In addition, with every click of the lead holder, a total distance is advanced, and maximum lead is released.

The clutch must be fully opened, and the lead must be pushed in to bring it back to normal. Traditionally the lead holder is more commonly used for technical rendering, not only that but also great use in all projects and plans, including sketching, writing, drawing.

What Is Mechanical Pencil?

what is mechanical pencil

Mechanical pencils are graphite lead tips for writing enclosed in specially designed length barrels instead of refilling new ink cartridges. In-depth, mechanical pencils are essentially a type of continuous solid pigment worn, the replaceable lead that is mechanically augmented.

Furthermore, a mechanical pencil opens just like a regular pen, but the pencil closes depending on the whole model; in this case, the long lead is gradually pushed inward by clicking on the pen’s tip and pressing the button to compress the barrel.

One of the reasons they are called mechanical pencils is because pencils made of metal or plastic are machine operated and have unique names such as click pencils, microtic pencils, automatic pencils, draft pencils, etc. The surprising but indisputable fact that mechanical pencils prevent excessive tree cutting is considered environmentally friendly.

Moreover, the most sophisticated advantage of using a mechanical pencil is that its lead is so delicate and thin that it is always sharp, which saves the hassle of sharpening for a lifetime.

Not only that, it allows uniform strokes and is reliable as well as durable, which is the complete opposite of graphite pencil made of wood. Additionally, this type of pencil is used in everything from engineering to fast handwriting.

Major Differences Between Lead Holder And Mechanical Pencil

Is the initial definition of the lead holder and mechanical pencil enough to help you choose any one pen so easily? Of course not.

There is a huge gap between some of these features and qualities, and it is entirely our responsibility to show you such differences. Let’s take a look at the differences between the lead holder and the mechanical pencil.

Lead Size and Grade

One finds the main difference between a traditional mechanical pencil and a lead holder in graphite diameter. This is because a standard lead holder accepts lead up to 2 mm in size but is capable of holding up to 5.6 mm. In addition, a larger diameter is more suitable for writing under heavy pressure because it provides line variation and clarity.

With the help of different sizes of lead s in ample area coverage and maintains the hardness grade, not only this. Additionally, soft lead is darkened by smooth lines on paper, while hard lead is lighter and less prone to smudging.

On the contrary, the lead holding capacity of mechanical pencils is quite versatile as they can be used with a lead radius of about 2 mm to 9 mm, but the most popular lead leads are 5 mm and 7 mm.

However, mechanical pencil lead is replaceable as well as mechanically stretched made of solid pigment core and graphite so that the point is not lost. Moreover, if one writes for fast writing, dense lead such as 0.5 mm lead is strong, and for heavy handwriting, thin lead such as 0.7 mm and 0.9 mm provides quite effective lines.


The lead holder typically holds the lead in the clutch mechanism process and can perceive the last little lead residue; that is why it is called a clutch pencil. Indeed, it also includes two types of advanced systems: Incremental Advanced Clutch Mechanism and Drop Clutch Mechanism.

Thus it expands the lead by pressing the clutch extender and closing the lead of the desired length to prevent it from falling off.

Conversely, the mechanical pencil mechanism process incorporates various systems to achieve the object, including springs, gears, cams, and levers. Specifically, these pencils use a spring mechanism without the use of graphite lead. Even it also generates enough energy to rely on friction to lift the lead.

Barrel Material

Lead holder barrels are usually made of plastic, wood, and metal, but lead holders are made of different materials depending on the brand. However, these three notable materials affect the weight of the pencil, such as plastic being light and affordable, the wooden lead holder is the taste and preference of many.

Likewise, the metal body maintains the professional look of the lead holder. Mechanical pencil barrels are usually built based on requirements such as 5 to 10 separate pencils with enough space to hold the lead.

Mechanical pencils are made of a combination of plastic, metal, rubber, and all materials, in order to maintain the balance between the material of the inner and outer barrel.

In addition, the barrel of this pencil allows you to write tirelessly for a long time by keeping it in line with the hand. However, both are important in forming an ideal pencil, whether a lead holder or a mechanical pencil barrel.

Barrel Diameter

The barrel of a lead holder is usually much thicker and more extensive than that of a mechanical pencil because it requires enough space to accommodate about 2 millimeters to 5 kilometers of lead.

Small barrels like the traditional mechanical pencil seem uncomfortable to insert into the lead folder. In mechanical pencils, on the other hand, the barrel maintains a standard radius, and at the end, a small hole holds the lead with a rubber band.

Moreover, if you want to pull the lead out too much, it expands with the inner rubber band and allows the lead to fall freely.

Mechanical Pencil vs Lead Holder: Which Is More Convenient and Why?

The mechanism and properties of the lead holder and the mechanical pencil are entirely different, both carrying certain qualities. However, even though lead holders and mechanical pencils are appropriate from their place, any one of them is more advanced and more helpful in some respects.

What’s more, the lead holder releases the internal clutch mechanism to hold the lead in place, while the mechanical pencil moves the lead forward with just one click.

In this case, understand that the mechanical pencil is relatively more valuable and convenient than the lead holder. So let us know about the standard qualities of mechanical pencils, which are not so well developed among the lead holders.

Different designs

The exterior beauty is undoubtedly desirable, with various sophisticated designs of glossy and cheerful black, brass, and silver mechanical pencils coming in different styles depending on different purposes and tastes of the person.

Consistent lines

Mechanical pencils are best for achieving reliability and detail because 0.3 mm lead is used to draw lines. In the case of creative projects, the mechanical pencil can draw fine lines, and the handwriting has a line path in the same width.

Moreover, the lead holder undoubtedly provides sharp lines, but the line can be misleading when writing.


Most mechanical pencils have their own eraser to remove any wrong or unwanted lines. Moreover, when the eraser is finished, the eraser in that size is readily available in the market and can be easily replaced. Additionally, the process of refilling with a mechanical pencil is so simple that you can do it at home.

The user only has to open the top of the pen and replace the new ink-filled cartridge lead. In addition, some models of mechanical pencil refills come with specially designed cartridges.


Almost all mechanical pencils allow complete removal when the lead is ultimately used and allow the casing to be used as a storage container for extra lead.

Cost-effective & convenient

You never have to sharpen a pencil lead like a lead holder. However, if you ever need to draw sharp lines, you have the advantage of using minimal lead. Not only that, you can use any mechanical pencil birth control only if you change the lead.

Now let’s come to the price of it, of course, mechanical pencils are also available at a much higher price, but at the same time and at a lower price the price of a pencil starts.

Final Words

If you have ever used a lead holder for all these professional tasks, be it an architect, engineer, artist, or artist, then your decision is not wrong if you are going to switch to a mechanical pencil later.

Because what we have described in detail in this article about the lead holder vs. mechanical pencil is probably quite different from the information heard from the people.

Correspondingly, despite the considerable gap between the lead holder and the mechanical pencil, they provide effective results in their own right, and both have advantages and disadvantages.

However, we will say that mechanical pencils are very good and there are a lot of facilities available, but for specific tasks, you must lean towards the lead holder.